Synology DS923 vs. FreeBSD with ZFS

by jmmvon 12/15/24, 7:30 PMwith 11 comments
by LeoPantheraon 12/19/24, 5:25 PM

I currently use TrueNAS Core on a (very) old 8-bay Dell Poweredge system, which I have been trying to find a replacement for. Suitable server hardware seems surprisingly expensive. Is there anything like the Synology that is just a bare-bones system I can run my own OS on? Since TrueNAS abandoned BSD, I've been wanting to switch to a plain FreeBSD system.

by freitasmon 12/19/24, 5:42 PM

I have a DS923+.

The first thing I did was install more RAM. Then everything I run is via Container Manager (their Docker version, which is a bit behind).

It is a great little machine. I use it for OneDrive and Google Drive backup. I use it for Office 365 and Google Workspace backups. And because it is always-on, I use it as the exit node for my Tailnet.

by jpk2f2on 12/19/24, 5:17 PM

I was hoping for more of a discussion on the data integrity side of things. One of the biggest reasons I run ZFS is to help ward off bitrot. My understanding with most if not all COTS NAS devices is they lack any scrubbing or data integrity tracking, much less ECC.

by xz18ron 12/21/24, 9:22 AM

I have a different Synology model (added extra RAM because it serves as an *arr server at the same time), and while I'm a big proponent of FOSS I must say that the 'peace of mind' section in this article really hits the mark. Hacking things together yourself is great, but when it comes to 20+ years of your digital data, I'd rather be safe. Also, encryption on and Synology QuickConnect (or whatever its Tailscale variant is called) off as a default.

by jcmfernandeson 12/19/24, 6:08 PM

These things are expensive... I ended up going with a DAS, a Terramaster D6-320. It was less than half the price (270€), suits my context (network-access isn't a must; the DAS is small enough to fit behind my TV), it doesn't "force" me to upgrade my network to 10gbps (expensive!) to get reasonable performance (it's USB 3.2 gen2 - 10gbps), and I can always make a DIY NAS out of it if one day I need to.