Apple wins $250 US jury verdict in patent case over Masimo smartwatches

by mistersquidon 10/26/24, 4:10 PMwith 43 comments
by Cheer2171on 10/26/24, 5:09 PM

Apple sued for violations of both design patents and tech patents. Apple won that Masimo's design infringes on Apple's design patents, for which they only asked for $250. Apple lost the other technology patent infringement parts of the case, for which they were asking for an injunction against Masimo selling their watches.

by runjakeon 10/26/24, 4:47 PM

In case the point is missed: Apple asked for $250, stating their cases was on principle. The courts aren’t slighting Apple.

by kylehotchkisson 10/26/24, 5:04 PM

Does this mean watches will get their blood oxygen sensors back? The news hasn’t yet seemed to clear this up for me

by gnabgibon 10/26/24, 4:30 PM

Small discussion (13 points, 17 hours ago, 5 comments) https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41950858

by HumblyTossedon 10/26/24, 4:28 PM

Title really doesn't do the article justice. There's a BIT more going on there than just the $250 that Apple got.

by jijjion 10/26/24, 5:45 PM

It looks like Apple's claims were related to the charging of the watch itself... Which brings me to my question of why not use standard USB Type-C charging ports instead of some proprietary charging method? It seems like from the very beginning it is a poor choice, on both parties, to charge a device using a non-standard charging device.

by paultopiaon 10/26/24, 7:08 PM

Can someone please explain why Apple doesn't just buy Masimo in a fight like this? Their market cap is like 5% of Apple's annual profit...

by mensetmanusmanon 10/26/24, 5:05 PM

Can you convert $250 to number of apple smart watches?

by stuartdon 10/26/24, 11:53 PM

http://archive.today/tgTd1

by andrewoneoneon 10/26/24, 7:14 PM

With this case it seems like Apple is just going to take them to court again and again until the well runs dry and Masimo’s patents can be purchased for pennies on the dollar. https://www.masimoconsumer.com/ Their products feel simultaneously like knock offs and 5 years old all at once.

by ryanobjcon 10/26/24, 9:17 PM

In every single press release Masimo complains apple hired away staff.

Um, you are in California. There are no non-competes.

You just are confessing every single time you can’t retain talented staff.

by wombatpmon 10/26/24, 9:23 PM

Any reason that Apple just doesn’t buy the company outright? Market cap is only 7.5B.

by amar0con 10/26/24, 8:40 PM

Why do hackernews people share links behind paywalls and pop-up's that want me to disable ad blocker ?

by bell-coton 10/26/24, 4:16 PM

Suggested Title change: s/wins $250/wins only $250.00/

That'd minimal editorializing - while making it quite clear that there is no missing 'K', let alone missing 'M'.